Key takeaways
- Compare the best HDMI audio extractors by video ceiling, ARC and eARC support, optical and analog outputs and EDID modes for receivers without HDMI.
The best HDMI audio extractor for most home theaters is the J-Tech Digital JTD18G-H5CH, because it passes 4K at 60Hz with HDR10 and HDCP 2.2 while splitting the sound to optical and 3.5mm outputs, and its EDID switch lets the source send either stereo or 5.1 audio. The OREI BK-931 is the pick when the TV itself is the source, since it works from an ARC or eARC port as well as from a source device, and passes 8K at 60Hz and 4K at 120Hz over HDMI 2.1. The J-Tech Digital JTECH-AE4KA covers the narrower ARC job, converting a TV’s ARC output to optical and RCA for an older receiver, the Tendak AV-226-BK adds a volume control and three audio output types at 4K at 60Hz, and the Amazon Basics extractor is the simple budget unit, with optical, coaxial and stereo outputs that can all run at once.
What separates these units is the video ceiling, where the audio comes from, and which outputs carry it. A source-side extractor sits between a streaming box, console or Blu-ray player and the display, and copies the audio out to a receiver or soundbar that has no HDMI input. An ARC extractor works the other way, taking the audio a TV sends back down its ARC or eARC port and converting it for equipment that only accepts optical or analog. Optical carries stereo PCM and 5.1 Dolby Digital or DTS; it cannot carry lossless formats, and no extractor here decodes a bitstream for its analog output, so the analog jacks need a PCM stereo source. Every figure below comes from the maker’s published data. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
Table of Contents
- How to Choose an HDMI Audio Extractor
- Quick Comparison
- 1. OREI BK-931 eARC 4K 120Hz Audio Extractor
- 2. J-Tech Digital HDMI Audio Extractor with ARC (JTECH-AE4KA)
- 3. J-Tech Digital 4K 60Hz HDMI Audio Extractor (JTD18G-H5CH)
- 4. Tendak HDMI Audio Extractor with Volume Control (AV-226-BK)
- 5. Amazon Basics 4K HDMI to HDMI and Audio Extractor Converter
- Before You Buy: EDID, Optical Limits and ARC
- FAQ
- Conclusion
- Product and ASIN Reference
How to Choose an HDMI Audio Extractor
Start by locating the audio. If the sound starts in a source device, a streaming stick, console or disc player, a source-side extractor goes in line before the display and copies the audio out on its way past. If the sound starts in the TV, from its own apps or tuner, only an ARC or eARC model can hear it, because that audio travels back down the HDMI cable from the TV’s marked port. The two jobs look similar on the shelf and are not interchangeable: a source-side unit with no ARC support, such as the JTD18G-H5CH below, will never extract a TV’s app audio, and a TV-side ARC unit has no use in a projector chain fed by a receiver-less source.
Next, match the video ceiling to the display chain. An extractor passes video through, and its ceiling becomes the system’s ceiling. For 4K at 60Hz with HDR, the unit needs HDMI 2.0 bandwidth of 18 Gbps and HDCP 2.2, which the OREI, both 4K J-Tech units and the Tendak provide. The Amazon Basics unit tops out at 4K at 30Hz, which suits broadcast and film sources but not a console set to 60Hz. At the top end, the OREI BK-931 is an HDMI 2.1 unit with 48 Gbps FRL bandwidth, passing 8K at 60Hz and 4K at 120Hz with HDCP 2.3, so it will not bottleneck a current console or a future 8K display.
Then count the audio outputs against the equipment receiving them. Optical is the common denominator for older receivers and soundbars, and coaxial appears on the Amazon Basics unit for receivers that prefer it. Analog stereo, over RCA or a 3.5mm jack, feeds powered speakers, older stereo amplifiers and headphone setups, but it only ever carries two channels, and only when the source is set to PCM. Finally, check the EDID control. The extractor reports capabilities back to the source, and a switchable EDID, 2CH or 5.1CH on the J-Tech and Amazon Basics units, is what stops a source from sending a format the connected receiver cannot play.
Quick Comparison
| Product | Max Resolution | ARC / eARC | Audio Outputs | EDID | Tier |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| OREI BK-931 | 8K at 60Hz, 4K at 120Hz | ARC and eARC | Optical, 3.5mm, HDMI | Not stated | Premium |
| J-Tech Digital JTECH-AE4KA | 4K at 60Hz | ARC | Optical, RCA | Not stated | Premium |
| J-Tech Digital JTD18G-H5CH | 4K at 60Hz | No | Optical, 3.5mm | 2CH / 5.1CH switch | Mid-range |
| Tendak AV-226-BK | 4K at 60Hz | No | Optical, 3.5mm, RCA | Not stated | Mid-range |
| Amazon Basics CEHFAE0101 | 4K at 30Hz | No | Optical, coaxial, 3.5mm | 2.0 / 5.1 channel select | Budget |
1. OREI BK-931 eARC 4K 120Hz Audio Extractor
The BK-931 is the extractor for a system built around a current TV. It is an HDMI 2.1 unit with HDCP 2.3, passing video at up to 8K at 60Hz and 4K at 120Hz over 48 Gbps FRL and 18 Gbps TMDS bandwidth, with HDR10+ and Dolby Vision pass-through, so a console or 8K source runs at its full format with the extractor in line. Uniquely here, it extracts from two directions: from a source device on its HDMI input, or from the TV itself over ARC and eARC, which is the route that gets a TV’s built-in apps and tuner into a soundbar or receiver that lacks an eARC input of its own.
The extracted audio leaves over optical and 3.5mm connections, alongside the HDMI path to the soundbar. OREI is explicit about the optical ceiling: the optical port supports up to 5.1 channels and does not downmix 7.1 audio, so a 7.1 stream sent only to the optical output can produce silence; lossless and height formats belong on the HDMI and eARC path, not the optical one. The chassis is the largest here at 5.5 x 2.75 x 0.75 inches and 11 ounces. For a newer TV feeding older audio equipment, or a mixed system that needs both directions covered by one box, this is the complete pick.
Specs
- Inputs: HDMI, ARC / eARC from a TV
- Max resolution: 8K at 60Hz, 4K at 120Hz
- Bandwidth: 48 Gbps FRL, 18 Gbps TMDS
- HDMI / HDCP: HDMI 2.1, HDCP 2.3
- HDR: HDR10+, Dolby Vision pass-through
- Audio outputs: Optical, 3.5mm, HDMI
- Optical limit: Up to 5.1 channels, no 7.1 downmix per OREI
- Dimensions: 5.5 x 2.75 x 0.75 in
- Item weight: 11 oz
- Warranty: Not stated
- Model: BK-931
- Tier: Premium
2. J-Tech Digital HDMI Audio Extractor with ARC (JTECH-AE4KA)
The AE4KA is built for one specific gap: a TV that sends its audio out over an ARC-enabled HDMI port, and a receiver or soundbar that cannot accept it because it only has optical or RCA inputs. The extractor takes the ARC feed from the TV and converts it to optical and RCA stereo, at video resolutions up to 4K at 60Hz for sources passed through it. That makes it the unit for a wall-mounted TV whose own apps are the main source, where the sound system predates ARC entirely.
Its audio support covers Dolby Digital, DTS and stereo, which is the full set an optical or analog connection can carry in any case. J-Tech lists the unit at six channels, matching the 5.1 ceiling of its digital output. What it does not do is eARC: lossless formats and height channels from a TV’s eARC port are beyond an ARC conversion, and buyers with an Atmos soundbar should look at the OREI above instead. J-Tech does not publish dimensions or a weight for this model in the data reviewed, so both are marked not stated below. For the plain ARC-to-optical-and-RCA conversion, done at 4K at 60Hz, this is the focused tool.
Specs
- Inputs: HDMI, ARC from a TV
- Max resolution: 4K at 60Hz
- ARC / eARC: ARC supported, eARC not supported
- Audio outputs: Optical, RCA stereo
- Audio formats: Dolby Digital, DTS, stereo per J-Tech
- Channels: 6
- Dimensions: Not stated
- Item weight: Not stated
- Warranty: Not stated
- Model: JTECH-AE4KA
- Tier: Premium
3. J-Tech Digital 4K 60Hz HDMI Audio Extractor (JTD18G-H5CH)
The H5CH is the standard source-side extractor, and the default for a streaming box, console or Blu-ray player feeding a display and a separate sound system. It passes 4K at 50 and 60Hz in YUV 4:4:4, plus 1080p at 120Hz and 144Hz for gaming displays, over HDMI 2.0b at 18 Gbps with HDCP 2.2, and passes 10-bit HDR10 and CEC. Audio leaves over optical SPDIF and a 3.5mm analog jack, and the EDID switch sets the negotiation: 2CH for stereo output to either jack, 5.1CH for multichannel over optical, with uncompressed LPCM supported.
The limits are stated plainly by the maker. The unit passes Dolby Digital and DTS; it does not decode them, so the analog jack needs the source set to PCM or it stays silent. It has no ARC function, so it cannot hear a TV’s own apps. J-Tech also names its incompatibilities: the third-generation Apple TV 4K (model A2843) and certain Comcast Xfinity boxes are not supported, nor are HDMI 1.2 sources or monitors made before 2005. Within those lines, it is the most completely specified extractor here, with high bit rate audio pass-through and sample rates up to 192 kHz.
Specs
- Contents: Extractor unit, DC 5V power adapter, user manual
- Inputs: 1 HDMI
- Max resolution: 4K at 50/60Hz (YUV 4:4:4), 1080p at 120Hz and 144Hz
- Bandwidth: 18 Gbps
- HDMI / HDCP: HDMI 2.0b, HDCP 2.2
- HDR: HDR10, 10-bit pass-through
- Audio outputs: Optical SPDIF, 3.5mm stereo
- EDID: 2CH / 5.1CH switch
- ARC: Not supported
- Audio sample rates: Up to 192 kHz
- Dimensions: Not stated
- Warranty: 1-year manufacturer warranty and lifetime technical support per J-Tech
- Model: JTD18G-H5CH
- Tier: Mid-range
4. Tendak HDMI Audio Extractor with Volume Control (AV-226-BK)
The Tendak covers the same 4K at 60Hz source-side job with the widest analog flexibility here. It passes 4K at 60Hz with HDR, 3D and YUV 4:4:4 color over HDMI 2.0 with HDCP 2.2, and it extracts to three outputs: optical SPDIF, a 3.5mm stereo jack and RCA left and right. Having both analog forms on one box matters in older systems, where the receiver may offer RCA only and the powered speakers 3.5mm only, and this unit feeds either without an adapter cable.
Its distinguishing feature is the volume control, a knob on the unit that adjusts the analog output level directly. That suits headphone and desktop-speaker setups fed from the 3.5mm jack, where the source device offers no convenient volume control of its own, and it is a feature none of the other four units here provides. Tendak publishes no dimensions, weight or EDID specification for this model in the data reviewed, so those are marked not stated below. For a 4K source feeding a mix of optical and analog equipment, with level control at the box, it is the flexible mid-range pick.
Specs
- Inputs: 1 HDMI
- Max resolution: 4K at 60Hz, YUV 4:4:4
- HDMI / HDCP: HDMI 2.0, HDCP 2.2
- HDR: HDR and 3D support per Tendak
- Audio outputs: Optical SPDIF, 3.5mm stereo, RCA stereo
- Volume control: Yes, on the unit
- EDID: Not stated
- Dimensions: Not stated
- Item weight: Not stated
- Warranty: Not stated
- Model: AV-226-BK
- Tier: Mid-range
5. Amazon Basics 4K HDMI to HDMI and Audio Extractor Converter
The Amazon Basics unit is the budget extractor, built into a metal housing, and its party trick is output count: optical Toslink, coaxial and 3.5mm stereo, with all three audio outputs able to work at the same time per the manual, so one source can feed a receiver on optical and a second device on analog without re-cabling. A select button toggles between 2.0 channel and 5.1 channel modes, with the 5.1 output carried on the Toslink and coaxial sockets, and Dolby Digital and DTS are supported.
The trade is the video ceiling. It supports 8-bit 4K at 30Hz, 12-bit 1080p at 60Hz and 3D formats, at 300 MHz and 3 Gbps per channel, which covers broadcast boxes, older consoles and film sources, and leaves 4K at 60Hz gaming and HDR sources to the units above it. Power comes over USB at 5 volts and 320 milliamps, drawn from a USB port or adapter, so there is no separate power brick to place. For a 1080p or 4K30 system that needs sound out of an HDMI source and into equipment without HDMI, it does the whole job at the lowest commitment here.
Specs
- Inputs: 1 HDMI
- Max resolution: 8-bit 4K at 30Hz, 12-bit 1080p at 60Hz, 3D
- Bandwidth: 300 MHz / 3 Gbps per channel
- Audio outputs: Optical Toslink, coaxial, 3.5mm stereo, all usable simultaneously per the manual
- Channel modes: 2.0 channel / 5.1 channel select button
- Audio formats: Dolby Digital, DTS
- Power: USB, 5 V, 320 mA
- Housing: Metal
- Dimensions: Not stated
- Item weight: Not stated
- Warranty: Not stated
- Model: CEHFAE0101
- Tier: Budget
Before You Buy: EDID, Optical Limits and ARC
EDID decides what the source believes is connected, and it is where extractor installs fail. If a receiver that cannot decode DTS is in the chain and the source sends DTS anyway, the result is silence, not an error message. The switchable EDID on the JTD18G-H5CH and the channel select on the Amazon Basics unit exist to pin that negotiation: set 2CH or 2.0 when anything analog is connected, and 5.1CH only when the optical or coaxial path ends at equipment that decodes Dolby Digital and DTS. When a new extractor produces picture but no sound, the EDID setting and the source’s audio format are the first two things to change.
Optical sets the second limit, and it is a hard one. A Toslink connection carries stereo PCM and 5.1 Dolby Digital or DTS, and nothing more: lossless formats such as Dolby TrueHD and DTS-HD Master Audio, and height formats such as Atmos, travel only over HDMI. An extractor cannot change that, and none of the five here decodes a bitstream for its analog output either, which is why the analog jacks need a PCM stereo source. ARC has the same shape of limit in the other direction. Plain ARC carries the same formats as optical; eARC is the version that carries lossless and height audio, and only the OREI BK-931 here works with eARC. Finally, an extractor only hears what passes through it or what the TV sends to its ARC port: a source plugged into a different TV input from the extractor’s chain is a source the extractor will never see.
FAQ
What is the difference between an HDMI audio extractor and an ARC extractor?
A source-side extractor sits between a source device and the display and copies the audio out as the signal passes through, so it hears only the sources plugged into it. An ARC extractor works from the TV’s ARC or eARC port and converts the audio the TV sends back, which includes the TV’s own apps and tuner as well as any source the TV passes through. The OREI BK-931 and the J-Tech JTECH-AE4KA work from ARC; the JTD18G-H5CH, Tendak and Amazon Basics units are source-side only.
Can an HDMI audio extractor send Dolby Atmos or lossless audio to my receiver?
Not over optical or analog. Optical carries stereo PCM and 5.1 Dolby Digital or DTS, and analog carries stereo only, so lossless and height formats cannot reach a receiver through those connections. Those formats travel over HDMI, including an eARC path: the OREI BK-931 passes them between a TV and soundbar over HDMI 2.1, which is the route to use when the audio equipment has an HDMI input that supports them.
Why is there no sound from the analog output of my extractor?
Because extractors pass bitstreams rather than decoding them. When a source sends Dolby Digital or DTS, the analog jack receives a format it cannot convert and stays silent. Set the source device to PCM stereo output, and set the extractor’s EDID or channel switch to its 2CH or 2.0 setting, and the analog output will carry the stereo signal. The digital optical output can keep carrying 5.1 at the same time on units whose EDID allows it.
Do I need a 4K at 60Hz extractor if my TV is 4K?
If any source in the chain runs at 4K at 60Hz, yes, because the extractor’s ceiling becomes the system’s ceiling: a 4K at 30Hz unit such as the Amazon Basics will hold a console or streaming box set to 60Hz down to 30Hz, and an HDCP 1.4 unit can refuse protected 4K content entirely. For 1080p and 4K30 film and broadcast sources the budget unit is sufficient. For a current console, or an 8K or 4K at 120Hz display, the HDMI 2.1 OREI BK-931 is the only unit here that will not bottleneck the chain.
Conclusion
Extractor buying starts with one question: where does the sound begin? If it begins in a source device, the J-Tech Digital JTD18G-H5CH is the default, with the full 4K at 60Hz specification, HDR10 and a switchable EDID, and the Tendak AV-226-BK covers the same job with three audio output types and a volume control. If the sound begins in the TV, the J-Tech JTECH-AE4KA converts a plain ARC feed to optical and RCA, and the OREI BK-931 is the complete unit, working from ARC and eARC as well as from sources, at HDMI 2.1 speeds up to 8K at 60Hz and 4K at 120Hz. The Amazon Basics extractor closes the list for 1080p and 4K30 systems that want optical, coaxial and stereo outputs running at once. Match the EDID to the receiver, keep lossless formats on HDMI, and any of the five will keep a good older sound system in service.
- Best HDMI Matrix Switchers: 5 Picks for Multi-Room Setups
- Best Optical Audio Cables: 5 Toslink Picks for TV Sound
- Best HDMI Splitters: 5 Ways to Mirror One Source on Two TVs
- Best HDMI Over Ethernet Extender Kits for Long Cable Runs
- Best Soundbars for TVs: 5 Picks for Movies and Sports
- Best Speaker Wire for Home Theater: 5 Spools Compared